Parker Kennedy Pays Lip Service To Abstractors
by Robert Franco
| 2007/10/17 |
Parker Kennedy, the Chairman and CEO of First American, spoke about the company at the Lehman Brothers 10th Annual Financial Services Conference. He addressed many issues, including the importance of the abstractors that search the public records.
I would say that the title -- the title search is essential to the issue of title insurance, and title insurance is essential to an efficient mortgage market.
...
Even though the government does a good job, it's hard to search the records. You've got to understand them. You've got to figure out how to summarize them. You've got to decide what's important, what can be ignored. It takes some skilled people. So the value proposition of the title search (inaudible) it's really the expertise of the people who do the search.
While it was good to see Mr. Kennedy realize how important skilled abstractors are to the process, it is obvious that First American does not embrace that concept. The company has some of the worst title search standards I have ever seen. Their search standards have been "dumbed down" to get a cheaper product and allow for title searches to be done online and overseas.
In fact, Mr. Kennedy boasts about their overseas operations.
Source of Title Blog ::
First American is a company that benefits greatly by offshore processing. Any data company benefits greatly, because you can move data to be worked on by others to anywhere in the world wherever it's most efficient. We have about 5500 people, for instance, in India alone. We have an equal number of people in the Philippines that are not employees of ours but that are dedicated to working on our products. So we're very committed to our offshore processing, and it's really been a good thing for our efficiency as a company.
...
And as I mentioned earlier, we have a lot of people in India. And it's easy to say we're going to send business to India; we're going to send functions to India. It's hard. You've got to have an infrastructure. We have a leadership infrastructure. We have over 5000 people in India. We're set up to move more and more functions to India. We do it throughout the Company. We haven't done it as fully as we can in Title Insurance. So when we say we're going to improve our margins, it's not just we hope, it's we will. We have put in motion the things that we need to do for those margins, and we'll start to see the benefits of that in fairly short order.
How many experienced abstractors could there be in India? I'm not sure you could have found anyone who even knew what a title search was in India five years ago. If you recall an article in The Economic Times, Winning The Title Bout in Style, one of the India outsourcing companies bragged about 40 days of training in the United States.
Just when Mr Kanth was wondering about the next steps, he met the president of a title company based out of Baltimore in 2003-2004. He told Mr Kanth that there was a refinance boom in the US which resulted in a huge backlog in terms of production. Incidentally, his brother M Sujay Kanth, who is now the COO of ESS, happened to be in the US to explore business opportunities. They took up this opportunity. This was their first break. They met with the title official and looked at the process. "Initially, we had no clue of what was going on and it was very hard to grasp. We took it as a challenge and Sujay got trained in their office for about 40 days after which we started the transition to my India office from 2004," the doc said.
Now, ESS has its own title insurance company in the US so it is basically involved in the entire process. But, as far as the India operations are concerned, it is handling most of the tasks other than disbursement.
The clients are primarily insurance companies, a few lenders also use the services -- a 70:30 split. The five top players in the US title industry are Fidelity National Financial, First American Title Insurance, LandAmerica Title Insurance, Stewart Title Guaranty and Old Republic Title Insurance. Most of the above-mentioned companies are in Fortune 500 league. ESS does business with two of the companies and are in a partnership with Stewart Title.
First American has lowered their title search standards, outsourced important functions to countries where English is a second language, and has even announced "automated title" products which they claim can produce the search and commitment in under 15 minutes. It takes a lot of nerve to make statements about how important skilled abstractors are after you have shown that you have very little regard for their services.
But, of course, Mr. Kennedy has to say that because if he admitted to taking short-cuts effecting the quality of the title search it would devalue their core product - title insurance. However, Mr. Kennedy is already on the record stating that "eventually title insurance won't be an important component of the product."
Here is an excerpt from the Forbes article, Inside America's Richest Insurance Racket, from November 2006:
"We get a little more automated every day," [Parker] Kennedy [,Chairman and CEO of First American,] says. "In the old days, if you wanted to double your business you had to double your people. Now you can double your business and increase your staff maybe 10%."
The tech push must continue, he says, because one day economic rationality and digital reality will catch up to the title industry. Real estate ownership records, always open to the public, are going online, alongside all sorts of other data. Today anyone can instantly learn a property's square footage, its sales price history, even view satellite photos, at virtually no cost. If records are instantly accessible and accurate, the need for title insurance will fade away. "Eventually insurance won't be an important component of the product," he allows.
So Kennedy hopes to harness digital technology to create a new business. Rather than broker one piece of information for an exorbitant cost, he hopes to collect all manner of real estate skinny and sell it to banks, insurers, real estate agents and direct marketers.
Somehow I doubt Parker Kennedy has ever done a title search. Maybe he just doesn't understand that he is talking out of both sides of his face. Those of us in the industry know how little First American really cares about skilled abstractors. When the regulators and the ratings agencies figure that out, perhaps they will take a closer look at the value (or lack thereof) of title insurance, rather than merely the cost of the premiums.
Robert A. Franco
SOURCE OF TITLE
rfranco@sourceoftitle.com
Categories: Abstractors, Title Industry
1622 words
|
3225 views
|
|
|